VOTE NO ON JUNEAU RECALL
Reward Persistent and Effective Leadership
UNDERSTANDING THE RECALL
WHY VOTE NO?
The reality behind this recall is 20+ years of declining student enrollment and prior board leadership unwilling to adjust the budget to this reality. School Board members rely on district staff to develop, monitor, and regularly report on budget changes. In November 2023, a multi-month audit confirmed there was a substantial failure to report critical financial information.
In response to the alarming audit and the departure of the finance officer, the Board authorized the new superintendent to hire an accountant to examine our budget exhaustively. In January 2024, as Board President, Deedie Sorenson notified the Assembly and our community of the findings – a severe budget deficit.
Next, we implemented strategies to address the issues which included:
a hiring freeze, securing a $3.9 million grant for building maintenance,
all while holding meetings to gather public input on the 2025 school budget and consolidation.
The board, administration, and staff should be commended for achieving a balanced budget revision for 2024, resulting in $600,000 positive balance. This is the deficit budget referenced in the Recall. We made difficult decisions for our schools in the 2025 budget. Decisions necessary to ensure our students continue to receive a great education.
The truth is that both Emil Mackey and Deedie Sorenson demonstrated responsible leadership and budgetary knowledge for years preceding the budget crisis.
Budget Documents
One complaint is that the Board was not "Transparent". All budget documents were available to the board an public in real time at: FY2025 Budget Documents - Google Drive
2024 BOARD OF EDUCATION BUDGET MEETING RECORDINGS
BOARD OF EDUCATION BUDGET MEETING RECORDINGS
**PASSCODES ARE LISTED BELOW EACH MEETING**
Below are all of the meeting recordings.
Despite claims by the recall supporters that the meetings were rushed and not open to the public, we have video. The truth is that the Board had over 20 meetings, some extending from 4:30pm - after midnight, to get the work done publicly and with extraordinary public input and comment.
-
January 9, 2024 Budget Work Session (FIRST MEETING DISCUSSING THE BUDGET CRISIS)
https://juneauschools-org.zoom.us/rec/share/S35dCxVIP-_koe5Xt6SbbcLZuLkwXmaU3EDJq9laxp0TD0MMV-cD3FRI3SsUjnyO.9AQvwMuWIrt7zFk6
Passcode: ?7i#hg9u
-
January 9, 2024 Regular Meeting
https://juneauschools-org.zoom.us/rec/share/7OqgpoFht6TprAsm3T3BE4ZJf_82FO2UwGGshy5eJeyLHUFh0x52KmHQ4VTmWk1N.iw-SzkMeIdxViYmEPasscode: As==3w0?
-
January 16, 2024 Special Meeting
https://juneauschools-org.zoom.us/rec/share/nyNcTod4qK-e_A6Jl5JcTTobGE6_RGvLYk5nob84_zCoNvwPO8RAsHOb3n0Kqt6T.S51QcKa2YwcsP3Q4
Passcode: !9I#p?9+
-
January 18, 2024 Board of Education Budget Process - Combined Site Council Meeting
https://juneauschools-org.zoom.us/rec/share/Y93LQD4xtalGvnfvEP41KDUMKf72TTq5mpTK11ghWw9VgNZZquLVC8zy4T_7OKd3.KJ5IOzKi4Zqnhwtf
Passcode: G248%YJ%
-
January 20, 2024 Board of Education retreat
https://juneauschools-org.zoom.us/rec/share/zyNK9jnfV9RekfJu33BdzJUvYZ_avh5MmecqxeCQDN_nB_Xj-rHk2QYT6JeiYp61.3C2X8bL6pfZf58ET
Passcode: d8Xt#t+=
-
January 23, 2024 Board of Education Work
Session https://juneauschools-org.zoom.us/rec/share/yeFluANI2Pany6drvoZOyfaLX8rIb2iZORFzbGjPTy3EASY_OxclMCTHrSvUtgNw.IK7Eq1Qbtib8dyHX
Passcode: gR!Vep7n
-
January 30, 2024 - Joint School Board and CBJ Assembly Meeting
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hf61JaVwIJg&t=489s
-
February 13, 2024 - Board of Education Work Session
https://juneauschools-org.zoom.us/rec/share/VRbfAiyon3h9fRjYSDvbbUyR7hA7CP_UJVH0YLdHJpz86LK36g2cQJD0VwL-CRs.xUDY0nTZkMHV3jzb
Passcode: @4^V9bcg
-
February 13, 2024 - Board of Education Regular Meeting
https://juneauschools-org.zoom.us/rec/share/FSb26Gvyj6TSVoWfXfL5pdtdVrISr67Oz4_v8ne4YvKEohcAcpHLC4BFynh0ekmb.abuU1MydmcPsNUa2
Passcode: 0k!G3g!f
-
February 15, 2024 - Board of Education Facilities Committee Meetin
https://juneauschools-org.zoom.us/rec/share/_LsH3D5DWe_qAXliUWyp__tu20JrOoksfCKXU9WNAARyGX4MEwb-rv8Ee8STaA7z.Vk66FWO8H-03woUd
Passcode: 14@!1skz
-
February 17, 2024 - Board of Education Work Session
https://juneauschools-org.zoom.us/rec/share/mXjA3XzsKg8IqwkRwobS2mMePahT7Q13xRvUK64KiW_ijUUwGb0bI_fHygVfQjs.fu43jZFVsIz3ZxZb
Passcode: 2Gw@5?Wc
-
February 22, 2024 - Board of Education Special Meeting
RECORDING 1
https://juneauschools-org.zoom.us/rec/share/jfa6eDFkYa8bKNIro3jn-cYJYiNum9jf-qsRmZuOFTbP-rHADIXxxyt5ZesNRd2N.NvxbA7BDaYj-b2Kh
Passcode: dE^23P##
-
RECORDING 2
https://juneauschools-org.zoom.us/rec/share/gu86mZ-smNg6yRbtWp6YPQxL9oTliXA5dFDlMBdEId403OYgiWoVNTE177E-QcFi.ObY3Fha0ei38t_y0?startTime=1708673972000
Passcode: dE^23P##
-
February 27, 2024 - Board of Education Special Meetin
https://juneauschools-org.zoom.us/rec/share/vcomwysls5wDuilPuapPWoMbMxMw9lGULfl_VUwP76EBV3isgpmnO5o39L1mNrPJ.t4t6X9QYre2LlMx-
Passcode: PO!QJe6i
-
March 7, 2024 - Board of Education Special meeting
https://juneauschools-org.zoom.us/rec/share/tIGwTQot3dcKaX6q23c9sc_UPOJrEyU04LTIqVhBMbTh_zg0_vS-KcSot_g1U8M.usOz8hpxDw4hdUhI
Passcode: $N#utN29
-
March 12, 2024 - Board of Education Work Session
https://juneauschools-org.zoom.us/rec/share/W0Ezj95-0YEXPw7avtBm2QMTg3CPMIaiZDgUhLqpxJtvqLOOvDPd9ylYv6zzjy_Z.pqmnd1YIZrje_bK_
Passcode: 7HGcQ#??
-
March 12, 2024 - Board of Education Regular Meetin
https://juneauschools-org.zoom.us/rec/share/zU69Woa5_Y4hFHbWpzVysOBJ5wORnMCD9CFUwEFjFqeMia1QlTX4Z91Y9F8-waXJ.bTr-FzvbRH_71x8Y
Passcode: CPDA0nu.
-
March 14, 2024 - Board of Education Special Meeting
https://juneauschools-org.zoom.us/rec/share/WZTl6qJCefF8mEYWmMEqGCfDS5pajimHg8T6rLmkYXwgb0iGr3qk4D2AyldlveGW.wROjD4GHD6QctJ7b
Passcode: $#FtZ85L
-
April 12, 2024 - Board of Education Finance Committee Meetinghttps://juneauschools-org.zoom.us/rec/share/04ZBkijjp4OP3zHUMHtNjFiOunRNJAA97Uu8Fqj7keXfSb42Gl3XQAOhcN6RqdjH.c39aU8XrJCoP7Eva
Passcode: VCQx!W1?
-
April 16, 2024 - Board of Education Work Session https://juneauschools-org.zoom.us/rec/share/cuI3OgbAv7iy7vJ-2gK2MzemRCZTM59-jz8g7JvbzrqOhmL1jrH_MXpzi7HwjIlB.xJTy-ACaSHqlZKD-
Passcode: u3!mnT#L
-
April 16, 2024 - Board of Education Regular Meeting (ADOPTION OF THE BUDGET)
-
https://juneauschools-org.zoom.us/rec/share/cgkh2clwRG8xisKtiqFMGfMp3eDbAYPO1EsnKhrJ-CbKgC0PzoqPF6PeqCP3Ng.nxxpm45zX_8fmM6T
Passcode: c9mh&3v^
A Basic Timeline Leading To the Budget Crisis:
-
As reported in the September 18, 2015 Juneau Empire, Emil Mackey recognized that both Juneau High Schools were at 3/5ths capacity and that maintaining two high schools was not sustainable and that consolidation or a more creative use of infrastructure would eventually be necessary (https://www.juneauempire.com/news/five-candidates-three-spots/).
-
6/5/2017, CBJ JSD Facility Master Plan: Draft Summary of Findings transmitted to JSD and CBJ. They observed, "The Juneau School District is currently experiencing a drop in enrollment. Enrollment projections do not show a significant increase in enrollment with high enrollment projections and low enrollment projections reflecting enrollment continuing to decline."
-
The report recommended:
-
Incorporation of the Charter School into JSD facilities.
-
Reorganization of grades to allow facility closures.
-
Reorganization from a two high school community, to a one high school community, and observed, "A revision of the Pupil Teacher Ratio of 24.5 pupils increased to 27 pupils, would create a capacity in JDHS that would allow consolidation of the two high schools."
-
-
-
10/17/2017 - Emil Mackey supported a work session for members to consider three question posed by CBJ:
-
Would JSD consider reorganization of grades at schools?
-
Would JSD consider closing an elementary or high school facility?
-
Would JSD consider relocating students from Marie Drake facility and moving administrative staff in building? Source, JSD Minutes from 10/17/2017: https://docs.google.com/document/d/15WI-fjWIHor_tQsLrItUncnPdYqUHg6E2WDr4d2rtQY/edit
-
-
2018 - Emil Mackey did not seek re-election so he could help with his newborn son, born June 2017.
-
In 2019, Emil Mackey ran for the school board. In his 2019 KTOO Candidate statement, he stated that one of the most pressing educational needs in the district was addressing deferred maintenance in the district and potential education cuts he believed Governor Dunleavy would attempt to impose (https://www.ktoo.org/elections/juneau-2019/candidate/emil-robert-mackey-iii/).
-
10/1/2019, Emil Mackey and Deedie Sorensen Elected to the Juneau School Board (https://www.ktoo.org/2019/10/01/2019-juneau-municipal-election-juneau-school-board/).
-
03/10/2020, Emil Mackey commented that he is not happy with the budget and feels it's piecemealed and not optimal. He has concerns about the curriculum and the TED program and feels that they need to consider these things between now and the next meeting. He is also concerned over the PTR levels and feels there is nothing else left to cut. He feels they need to look at radical changes to the district such as consolidating schools and redistricting the boundaries (https://docs.google.com/document/d/1qhaGNi_ZfZSvgB5U5kX66uqdTki8UwiP_baKZScz48Y/edit).
-
In his 2022 re-election, Emil Mackey recognized the increasing fiscal pressures and in his KTOO Candidate Statement, he said, "We can’t continue to face flat funding by raising PTR (pupil-to-teacher ratio). I would like for us to find other efficiencies, even if that means consolidating schools potentially, or finding other efficiencies to where we can get more bang for the buck with existing resources, because the state is obviously not going to step up to that and do adequate funding for schools. We’re going to be stuck with with flat funding from 2006 levels as far as the eye can see (https://www.ktoo.org/elections/2022-juneau-municipal-election/candidate/emil-r-mackey-iii/).
-
10/18/2022 - Emil Mackey commented on the economic realities that they will be facing as a Board. There will have to be some tough choices ahead. He feels that they need to consider consolidation and they need to prepare for that reality. The Board needs to engage the community and get ahead of the problem and figure out how to solve it (https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Ny_PDS9Yth48penDevF1xRUfJmBZ-_kH6T5PvlnyI5s/edit).
-
11/08/2022 - In response to the Audit Report showing increasing structural deficits (https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1hAqBdsXvel9QeG6-fqCubhd0MpDnWNzR), Emil Mackey encouraged members to think about what’s ahead and that they will face structural challenges within the budget (https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Pi9thvb3Sd6W1ioQZAMl837SowsZJf__t6hpgNe3_LQ/edit).
-
1/21/2023 - Emil Mackey presents "consolidation concepts" and asks the board to engage the community in "revisioning" the district to counter ongoing structural deficits (Starts 31:41 Zoom Recording Password 7U2+f+Em)
-
2/24/2023 - Deedie Sorenson and Emil Mackey vote against assumptions that the BSA will be increased $400 for SY 23-24. Deedie stated, "“This makes me nervous." Emil Mackey stated, “If this fails, not only will all of us look like the laughing stock of Alaska, individually and collectively, but it will also lead to very rapid and catastrophic cuts in order to make it right in the end" (https://www.ktoo.org/2023/02/24/juneau-school-board-to-build-budget-around-moderate-state-funding-increase/).
-
02/28/2023 - During Budget revision discussions, Emil Mackey voted against every assumption of a BSA increase due to the likelihood of a veto by Governor Dunleavy (https://docs.google.com/document/d/1kU8EK9pfJfK9r7GfuyAePbe1S3HWNR1Q8rTpDedq9oI/edit) and (Starting 23:37 Zoom Recording password #s@Uhuh3).
-
03/07/2023 - In response to the grueling budget debates on class sizes, enrollment assumptions, and BSA assumptions, Emil Mackey spoke about revisioning the district for the future. He acknowledged that he is exhausted and the possibility of stepping down from his Board position (https://docs.google.com/document/d/1_l9PRU5WYWvljP7ckxkA1JRgLX28PDkZtmo6MN0YE84/edit).
-
04/22/2023 - Board discusses a future public process for potential changes to efficiently utilize our resources & facilities to improve educational outcomes (https://docs.google.com/document/d/1sDSegY_7tt_NQNrYff68rqn55A7TnE2A4BK-ZB5FVgk/edit).
-
06/01/2023 - Governor Dunleavy vetoed 50% of the 1-time BSA increase (https://www.ktoo.org/2023/06/19/dunleavy-slashes-education-funding-boost-as-part-of-budget-vetoes/) reducing the 1-time BSA increase to $340/student; creating a 758,000 shortfall in the approved budget (https://www.ktoo.org/2023/06/21/dunleavys-education-funding-veto-leaves-juneau-school-district-with-budget-gap/).
-
06/29/2023 - State of Alaska sent a letter to JSD objecting to supplemental non-instructional aid being given to the city (https://www.juneauempire.com/news/state-challenges-juneaus-outside-the-cap-funding-to-district/).
-
11/16/2023 - Juneau School District presents first budget projections to Site Councils with a projected $5.89 mil deficit: $1.94 mil from prior year, and a projected $1.05 mil for the next year to be budgeted.
-
11/29/2023 - Board is notified of the resignation of the Finance Director via email (https://www.ktoo.org/2023/12/15/the-juneau-school-districts-administrative-services-director-has-resigned/).
-
Week of 01/09/2024 - School Board is notified that the interim Finance Director has found the budget deficit to be $9.5 million rather than the anticipated $5.89 million (https://www.ktoo.org/2024/01/09/juneau-school-district-faces-9-5-million-deficit/).
-
01/16/2024 - A public meeting is held where the Public is presented with the Budget Crisis estimating a $9.5 mil deficit combined for prior year (2023), current year (2024), and future year (2025) (https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/15Jo2pGvzwJ7sLd4bq03FjCBuMsnVk8ZP).
-
Through the next 3 months, President Sorensen, a teacher for 37 years in the Juneau School District, led the board through the most difficult budget crisis in JSD History. Thanks to her leadership, the district was able to turn down the temporary loan offered by CBJ and balance the budget by June 1, 2024. See Budget Documents (https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/15Jo2pGvzwJ7sLd4bq03FjCBuMsnVk8ZP) and meetings (https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/15hJhJwyetQE4shVU7fBimCBN3oExAYpD)
The truth is that this budget crisis was identified years in advance by Emil Mackey and Deedie Sorensen, but it took a new board to have the will to solve it. That is not mismanagement nor incompetence. That is leadership. Removing President Sorenson and Vice President Mackey is not only holding the wrong people accountable, but will have a chilling effect on future boards and leadership to be proactive and incentivize inaction; possibly leading to future crises.